Biology & Philosophy Humanities and social sciences

What is ‘natural’ about naturalistic neuroscience?

Nemati, Nedah
Springer Nature · 2026-03-11 · DOI 10.1007/s10539-026-10006-y

Abstract

Recent advances in neuroscience have introduced a wave of technologies and experimental paradigms aimed at studying animal behavior under more natural conditions. These approaches promise to reconcile the control of laboratory settings with the complexity of real-world environments. Although these methods, here collectively termed naturalistic neuroscience, are often regarded as groundbreaking, this paper critically assesses their conceptual underpinnings and methodological consequences. Specifically, I examine the assumptions held by proponents of what I call the ‘conventional framework’ of naturalistic neuroscience, who seek to more accurately capture animals’ true, unaltered behavior. By closely attending to experimental practices involving nonhuman animal models, I show how distinct theoretical assumptions shape what is meant by naturalistic and how these differences challenge an often-invoked ideal of methodological pluralism. I discourage treating naturalistic neuroscience as a unified enterprise, arguing that the conventional discourse obscures the diversity of scientific aims and practices, both fostering theoretical fragmentation and impeding efforts to unify the study of behavior.

Read at publisher →