Crime, Law and Social Change Law
“Spaces we don’t control”: organizationally constrained guardianship and hazing prevention in higher education
Abstract
Hazing remains a persistent feature of U.S. higher education despite expanding legal mandates, institutional policies, and prevention initiatives, raising questions about how universities exercise guardianship in efforts to reduce student harm. Drawing on Routine Activities Theory (RAT), this qualitative study examines how student affairs administrators understand and respond to hazing prevention challenges within contemporary higher education settings. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 19 student affairs professionals recruited from a national survey of 143 administrators. Findings indicate that administrators frequently described hazing as occurring in environments characterized by limited institutional access and oversight, including off-campus housing, commuter settings, and privately controlled residences. Participants identified jurisdictional boundaries, resource limitations, reporting challenges, and institutional commitments to student autonomy as constraints on prevention efforts. Rather than describing guardianship as absent, administrators portrayed themselves as responsible for hazing prevention while lacking the authority, access, and capacity necessary to exercise effective oversight across many high-risk environments. These conditions produced a form of organizationally constrained guardianship in which responsibility exceeded practical control. Participants therefore emphasized education, relationship-building, and risk management strategies over direct supervision. Extending RAT to the organizational context of higher education, this study demonstrates how institutional structures shape guardianship capacity and highlights the need for prevention approaches that address jurisdictional fragmentation and strengthen oversight beyond campus boundaries.