Evolutionary Ecology Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

A multi-species experiment using artificial seed ageing shows little evidence for an invisible fraction problem

Klepka, Lea, Franks, Steven J., Liepelt, Sascha, Bucharova, Anna
Springer Nature · 2026-10-14 · DOI 10.1007/s10682-026-10424-0

Abstract

Non-random mortality of seeds in storage can result in a change in mean adult traits known as the “invisible fraction problem”. This issue can bias the results of resurrection studies and pose challenges for restoration. While this phenomenon has been documented, it remains unclear how relevant the invisible fraction problem is across wild species. To address this knowledge gap, we simulated long-term storage by exposing seeds of 6 grassland species to artificial ageing (60% relative humidity, 45 °C). We then hand-pollinated individuals within each treatment, using self-pollination for selfing species and cross-pollination within treatments for outcrossing species, to produce a second generation free from direct storage condition effects. In a common garden experiment, we compared the second-generation offspring of plants grown from aged seeds to those from fresh seeds to test for evolutionary consequences of storage. Artificial ageing strongly affected germination and adult plant traits in the first generation, confirming substantial direct storage condition effects. However, these effects largely disappeared in the second generation. Offspring of plants from aged seeds showed slightly delayed germination, while all other traits remained unaffected. We conclude that, despite the direct effects of seed storage on the first generation, the non-random loss of certain genotypes during storage seems to be of no major concern. However, subtle evolutionary consequences cannot be fully excluded. While population trait means may not shift dramatically, storage condition effects should still be considered when using stored seeds for ecological restorations or resurrection studies.

Read at publisher →