Crime Prevention and Community Safety Law

Live-action police simulations and short-term changes in individual perceptions of legitimacy

Wade, Lee, Harms, Joshua, Stickle, Ben
Springer Nature · 2026-10-16 · DOI 10.1057/s41300-026-00260-3

Abstract

High-profile incidents of police use of force have intensified public scrutiny of law enforcement, particularly regarding perceptions of procedural fairness and legitimacy. This study examined whether participation in live-action simulated police-public interactions (traffic stops and foot-patrol contacts) altered participants’ perceptions of procedural fairness, distributive fairness, and obligation to obey police authority. Seventy-four participants completed pre- and post-simulation surveys; 93% were college students. Paired-samples t -tests showed statistically significant increases in procedural fairness, distributive fairness, and obligation to obey, with small-to-moderate effect sizes. OLS regressions indicated a marginal association in which Black participants reported larger gains in procedural fairness than non-Black participants. That coefficient is exploratory ( n = 16), most other demographic variables were not significant at that threshold and the models explained little of the variation in attitude change. The findings offer preliminary support for simulated interactions as a tool for producing small attitude shifts in a university sample. Replication of outside student samples is needed.

Read at publisher →