Journal of Police and Criminal Psychology Law
Bridging the Silence: A Scoping Review to Facilitate the Development of an Interview Protocol for Minimally Speaking and Nonspeaking Individuals
Abstract
Individuals with disabilities are estimated to be three to four times more likely to experience victimization than their peers, highlighting the importance of ensuring that forensic interviewing practices are accessible to minimally speaking and nonspeaking individuals. In this context, nonverbal evidence collection refers to the use of nonverbal forms of communication (e.g., gestures, drawings, augmentative and alternative communication [ACC] systems, behavioural demonstrations or visual responses) to elicit information during investigative interviews. However, research on investigative interviewing of minimally speaking and nonspeaking individuals is extremely limited. This scoping review examined the extent to which nonverbal evidence collection methods are discussed within the literature and the techniques currently used during investigative interviews. Systematic searches, following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, were conducted using eight databases for peer-reviewed studies that examined methods used to support nonverbal communication and evidence during investigative interviews. In total, 27 studies were included in the review. Findings revealed a critical gap: while nonverbal evidence collection methods are commonly used to support verbal communication, their effectiveness for minimally speaking or nonspeaking individuals remains underexplored. Future research should directly examine the utility of nonverbal evidence collection methods in populations with limited verbal capacity and work towards developing standardized, validated interviewing approaches that incorporate nonverbal and alternative forms of communication.