International Journal of Ethics Education Political Science and International Relations
Rethinking ethical deliberation in a contested world: an Islamic pedagogical framework for ethics education
Abstract
Contemporary societies are increasingly shaped by moral disagreement, value pluralism, and competing ethical commitments, raising important questions about the aims and practices of ethics education. Current debates in the field differ on whether ethics education should primarily cultivate moral reasoning, character formation, or dialogical engagement. While these approaches have generated valuable insights, they provide limited guidance on how learners can engage constructively with persistent ethical disagreement in contested social environments. This limitation reveals a significant theoretical and pedagogical lacuna: ethical deliberation remains insufficiently developed as a distinct educational capacity within existing frameworks of ethics education. This article argues that Islamic moral epistemology offers underexplored resources for rethinking ethical deliberation in contexts of moral contestation and pluralism. Drawing upon key concepts within Islamic moral epistemology, including reflective contemplation ( tafakkur ), reasoned reflection ( taʿaqqul ), consultative deliberation ( shūrā ) , ethical responsibility ( masʾūliyyah ), and respectful disagreement ( adab al-ikhtilāf ), the article develops an Islamic pedagogical framework for cultivating ethical deliberation as a formative educational capacity. The proposed framework moves beyond approaches centred primarily on the transmission of moral knowledge or the acquisition of analytical reasoning skills and instead emphasises the formation of learners capable of responsible judgement, intellectual openness, and constructive engagement with disagreement. The article advances a conceptual model of ethical deliberation by demonstrating how concepts within Islamic moral epistemology can be translated into pedagogical practices that support meaningful ethical engagement across diverse perspectives. By bringing Islamic moral epistemology into conversation with contemporary scholarship on ethics education, the study offers a distinctive theoretical contribution and a pedagogically actionable framework for cultivating ethical deliberation in pluralistic societies. In doing so, it advances an integrated model through which educators can cultivate the deliberative capacities required for responsible participation in contested social worlds.