Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries Водные науки
DNA barcoding reveals a disconnect between international regulation and retail reality: identifying critically endangered mobulid rays in a major global trade hub
Аннотация
Manta and devil rays (mobulids) are experiencing severe global population declines driven by the international trade in their gill rakers. Gill rakers are a high-value commodity marketed within Traditional Chinese Medicine contexts, their consumption is claimed to bring many health benefits, from preventing mild aliments to curing cancer. Yet, despite this demand and the associated declines, the species composition of mobulids involved in the trade at major hubs such as Singapore remains poorly documented and understood. Here, we perform the first comprehensive DNA barcoding assessment of the gill raker trade in Singapore, a regionally and globally significant transit and consumer node within the mobulid and gill raker trade. This assessment was performed immediately prior to addition of all 10 recognised mobulid species to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) Appendix I. We attempted to DNA barcode 439 gill raker samples sold under the generic labels of "fish gills" or “ peng yu sai ” and identified a total of five mobulid species traded in Singapore. This trade was dominated by the Spinetail Devil Ray ( Mobula mobular ) and the Sicklefin Devil Ray ( Mobula tarapacana ), both of which are Critically Endangered. Collectively, 84% of the samples identified in this study came from Critically Endangered species. Discrepancies between our results and those reported in the CITES trade database suggest significant underreporting and the likely use of ambiguous labelling practices to circumvent regulations. These results provide a critical baseline for monitoring the efficacy of recently imposed Appendix I protections.