Nature Human Behaviour Behavioral Neuroscience

Trial-by-trial fluctuations in decision criterion shape confidence

Vloeberghs, Robin, Navarrete Orejudo, Lara, Urai, Anne E., Desender, Kobe
Springer Nature · 2026-11-01 · DOI 10.1038/s41562-026-02544-y

Abstract

Vloeberghs et al. show that variability in confidence reflects trial-to-trial fluctuations in the decision criterion. Many decisions are accompanied by confidence. One influential view couched within signal detection theory views confidence as the distance between a decision variable and a static decision criterion. However, recent work suggests that the criterion undergoes trial-by-trial fluctuations. Here, combining theory and model simulations, we predict that fluctuations in the decision criterion shape confidence. In 15 datasets, trial-by-trial estimates of the decision criterion were obtained with the hierarchical model for fluctuations in criterion. Across datasets, we confirmed our pre-registered hypothesis that confidence is shaped by a single-trial criterion state. This effect was found in 14 out of 15 datasets, indicating a robust pattern across a variety of paradigms and confidence scales. Beyond self-reports, the effect was also observed in reaction times, pupil-linked arousal and a neural signature of confidence. Our results show that variability in confidence, often treated as noise, actually reflects genuine sensitivity to the current state of the (fluctuating) decision criterion.

Read at publisher →