Nurses' Communication of Their Critical Thinking, Clinical Reasoning and Clinical Judgement When the Escalation of Care of the Acutely Deteriorating Patient Is Indicated: A Qualitative Exploratory Study

Sonya Jones, Janie Brown, Melanie Barlow, Shelley Gower
Nursing Open · Wiley · 2026-11-17 · DOI: 10.1002/nop2.71055

Аннотация

ABSTRACT Aim To determine how nurses communicate critical thinking, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgement when the escalation of care of the acutely deteriorating patient was indicated. Design Qualitative exploratory design. Methods Underpinned by communication accommodation theory. Twenty‐seven nurses (speakers), or senior nurses ( n = 5) or doctors ( n = 5) (receivers) were interviewed about escalation practice. Results Most nurses used critical thought and clinical reasoning when making clinical judgements about escalation but rarely said so. Nurse‐speakers were accommodative when escalating to receivers but, if they perceived they were unsuccessful or felt patient safety was compromised, they became divergent and nonaccommodative. Four themes were constructed: the influence of communication accommodation, relationships and intergroups, healthcare culture and the use of protocols and decision‐making. Conclusions Some nurses paused briefly to gather objective information about patients and think critically before escalating care (or not). At times, they leveraged professional relationships when communicating their critical thinking, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgement were not accommodated. Implications The development of a conceptual framework that integrates the afferent limb of the rapid response system with communication accommodation theory may be effective for nurses seeking to articulate critical thinking, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgement as part of their escalation decision‐making. Impact The decision‐making processes that underpin escalation practice are based in critical thought and not risk taking as currently perceived. Recommendations A place within observation charts be reserved for nurses to document their critical thoughts, clinical reasons, and clinical judgements is proposed for future evaluation. Speakers should be taught how to frame escalation requests to receivers that foster decision‐making in a foundation of communication accommodation theory. Reporting Method COREQ. Public Contribution A consumer representative provided input into screening questions. What Does This Paper Contribute to the Global Clinical Community? Nurses apply critical thought, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgements when communicating about deteriorating patients.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи