English Teaching & Learning Language and Linguistics
ESL Teachers’ Lived Experiences of Professional Development for Classroom-Based Assessment: A Qualitative Case Study in Malaysian Secondary Schools
Abstract
The implementation of Classroom-Based Assessment (CBA) in Malaysia represents a shift from examination-oriented assessment toward more formative, continuous, and learner-centred practices. This reform requires English as a Second Language (ESL) teachers to exercise professional judgement in designing assessment tasks, interpreting learner performance, and providing feedback. However, translating policy expectations into classroom practice requires professional learning that extends beyond one-off training events. This study examines teacher professional development (TPD) for CBA implementation through the theoretical lens of legitimate peripheral participation (LPP). A qualitative case study was conducted with four curriculum trainers and six secondary school ESL teachers in Penang, a state located on the north-western coast of Peninsular Malaysia comprising Penang Island and Seberang Perai. Data were collected through one semi-structured interview with each participant and document analysis and analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Three forms of TPD emerged: workshop-based professional learning, expert modelling, and trainer-led collaborative coaching. Workshops provided legitimate access to CBA policy and curriculum discourse but largely positioned teachers as recipients of information. Expert modelling provided access to assessment artefacts and examples of practice, although its usefulness was constrained when exemplars did not correspond to teachers’ classroom contexts. Trainer-led collaborative coaching created greater opportunities for dialogue, negotiation, and engagement with authentic assessment practices, although teachers demonstrated different degrees and forms of participation. The study contributes to research on teacher professional development by extending LPP to the context of assessment reform and showing that professional learning is shaped not simply by the type of TPD provided, but by the quality of teachers’ access to, interaction with, and participation in assessment practices. The findings highlight the need for sustained, collaborative, and context-responsive TPD to support the enactment of CBA in ESL classrooms. 馬來西亞推動「課室本位評量」(Classroom-Based Assessment, CBA), 象徵評量制度逐漸從考試導向轉向重視形成性、持續性及以學習者為中心的評量實踐。此項改革要求英語為第二語言 (English as a Second Language, ESL) 的教師運用專業判斷, 設計評量任務、詮釋學生的學習表現, 並提供適切的回饋。然而, 要將政策要求轉化為實際的課堂教學與評量實踐, 教師所需的專業學習不 能僅依賴一次性的培訓活動。本研究以「合法周邊參與」(legitimate peripheral participation, LPP) 為理論視角, 探討教師在落實課室本位評量過程中所經歷的專業發展。研究採質性個案研究設計, 以馬來西亞檳城州的四位課程培訓員及六位中學ESL教師為研究參與者。檳城州位於馬來西亞半島西北部, 由檳城島與威省組成。研究資料透過每位參與者各一次的半結構式訪談及文件分析蒐集, 並採用反思性主題分析法進行分析。研究分析辨識出三種教師專業發展形式:工作坊式專業學習、專家示範, 以及培訓員主導的協作輔導。工作坊為教師提供接觸課室本位評量政策及課程相關論述的正當參與機會, 但教師在此類活動中多半處於資訊接收者的角色。專家示範則讓教師有機會接觸評量相關文件、成果及實務案例, 但當示範案例與教師實際面對的課堂情境存在落差時, 其實用性便受到限制。相較之下, 培訓員主導的協作輔導提供了更多對話、協商及參與真實情境中評量實踐的機會, 但教師的參與程度與方式仍有所差異。本研究將合法周邊參與理論延伸應用於評量改革的脈絡, 藉此深化對教師專業發展的理解。研究結果指出, 教師專業學習的發展並非僅取決於所接受的專業發展活動類型,也受到教師能否接觸評量實務、如何與他人互動, 以及實際參與評量實踐的品質所影響。研究發現進一步凸顯, 為支持課室本位評量在ESL課堂中的落實, 教師專業發展應具備持續性、協作性, 並能回應教師實際教學情境的需求。