Educational Psychology Review Education

Considering Cognitive Load When Exploring Before Instruction: The Potential Role of Element Interactivity

DeCaro, Marci S., Bego, Campbell R., Thompson, Angela K., Patrick, Ryan J.
Springer Nature · 2026-10-03 · DOI 10.1007/s10648-026-10223-7

Abstract

Exploring a new concept before instruction can promote students’ interest and deepen conceptual understanding compared to typical instructional methods—but does not always. Extending prior research, we examined whether the complexity of the exploration activity can limit its conceptual benefits. In Study 1, undergraduate first-year engineering students ( N = 388) learned common programming errors. Students in the instruct-first order received a lecture and practice activity targeting three error types. Students in the explore-first order explored the activity before lecture. Afterwards, students completed a survey and posttest assessing basic facts and concepts. Compared to the instruct-first order, students in the explore-first order scored lower on the posttest, reported equal interest/curiosity, and higher cognitive load. Studies 2a ( N = 393) and 2b ( N = 402) examined this instructional sequencing while varying task complexity (element interactivity). Study 2a (complex activity condition) again targeted three error types, and results overall replicated Study 1. Study 2b (simple activity condition) split the error types into three activities, interleaved with mini-lectures. Results showed the opposite pattern. Exploring first boosted conceptual knowledge, and equalized fact knowledge between orders. Exploring first also led to higher interest, curiosity, and cognitive load than receiving instruction first. Findings represent ecologically-valid, suggestive evidence, though with small to very small effect sizes. In accordance with cognitive load theory, it may be important to consider element interactivity when designing exploration activities. Exploration activities with smaller conceptual units may help learners discern important conceptual features and deepen understanding.

Read at publisher →