Moscow–Siberia–Kazakhstan: Disputes over Hierarchies and Conflicts of Competencies (1920–1921)

npj Natural Hazards · Springer Nature · 2026-08-30 · DOI: 10.1134/S1019331626602306

Аннотация

Abstract The article analyzes the history of the interaction of the Moscow center, the Bolshevik leadership of Siberia, and the leadership of the Kyrgyz (Kazakh) ASSR in the context of the demarcation of Siberia and Kazakhstan in 1920–1921. The “Siberians” were supporters of the creation of an autonomous republic, but they quite reasonably doubted the Bolshevik orthodoxy of its leadership, the ability of the party-state structures of the Kyrgyz (Kazakh) ASSR to solve effectively, under emergency conditions, the food-supply and military questions, and to ensure the security of the internal territories and the external borders. The claims of the Siberian party-state structures to power and control over the newly minted autonomy inevitably spilled over into disputes over hierarchies and conflicts of competencies, in which Moscow acted as the supreme arbiter. The rivalry between Siberia and Kazakhstan was aggravated by the fact that the Akmola and Semipalatinsk oblasts (governorates), formally included in the Kyrgyz (Kazakh) ASSR, in fact remained for about another year under the direct administration of the Siberian Revolutionary Committee. As a result, the transfer of competencies from the leadership of Siberia to the leadership of the Kyrgyz (Kazakh) ASSR dragged on until the autumn of 1921 and was permitted only to the extent that the corresponding apparatuses of the autonomy were organized, capable of ensuring the resolution of questions vitally important for the Bolsheviks. On the whole, the concrete circumstances of the creation of the Kazakh autonomy give grounds to note the ambivalence of the Soviet national project already at its origins, where the Bolsheviks’ “ethnophilia” was limited by political pragmatism.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи