Individuation Before Progressivity: Research Programme Reconstruction in the Modern Synthesis–Extended Evolutionary Synthesis Debate

Xu, Xiaochen
Evolutionary Biology · Springer Nature · 2026-10-31 · DOI: 10.1007/s11692-026-09683-0

Аннотация

Debate over the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis (EES) has centred on whether it should be understood as a development within the Modern Synthesis (MS) or as a research programme with a relatively independent identity. Existing Lakatosian analyses often move directly to assessments of theoretical relations or progressivity, while paying less attention to how the research programme that serves as the unit of appraisal is individuated. This paper reconstructs the debate as a problem of programme individuation. The MS–EES relationship exhibits both continuity in theoretical and formal resources and reorganisation in explanatory tasks, causal organisation, and theoretical status, but these changes are insufficient by themselves to determine programme identity. Programme individuation therefore requires a constrained reconstruction of historical and theoretical materials along three interrelated dimensions: programme scale, programme-constitutive structure, and diachronic identity. Such reconstruction need not be unique, but it cannot be arbitrary. Different programme maps also alter the structure of Lakatosian appraisal. Developments within a single programme trajectory call for intra-programme appraisal; independently individuated programmes lacking a methodologically relevant comparative relation permit only parallel appraisal; and inter-programme appraisal becomes possible only when both programme distinctness and the relevant comparative relation have been justified. Even then, internal progressivity, comparative standing, and programme replacement must be assessed separately. Programme individuation is therefore not merely a background classification for progressivity appraisal, but a justificatory prerequisite for establishing its unit of appraisal and the comparative relations it presupposes. This methodological requirement is captured by the principle of individuation before progressivity.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи