International Journal of Global Business and Competitiveness Бизнес и менеджмент
Governance mode in Vertical Coopetition: Analytical Propositions and a Boundary Case from a Very Small Firm
Аннотация
Vertical coopetition, the simultaneous cooperation and competition of firms at different stages of a value chain, remains theoretically immature. It is unclear whether it exists among SMEs and how it differs from subcontracting. This article distinguishes vertical coopetition from horizontal coopetition and subcontracting, and proposes an integrated definition in which rivalry over value capture or market access, not vertical position alone, identifies coopetition. It then examines an exploratory, documentary single case, a very small French firm and its industrial partners, reconstructed from three press articles and four documents published by the firm, which document its collaboration with the manufacturing partner Navtis on two projects: the 20 kW P154 hydrokinetic turbine of the FEDER-co-financed MegaWattBlue project and a demonstration of the smaller P66 turbine. The case works as a boundary case: cooperation with the manufacturing partner is documented, rivalry is not, and the relationship therefore cannot be read as coopetition on this evidence. Its governance mechanisms are largely undocumented in public sources. Drawing on the literature, the article proposes that legal, relational, and transactional governance mechanisms are combined and calibrated to power asymmetry, resource criticality, and sectoral context. Because the data are secondary and the case is unique, the results are analytical propositions to be tested, not generalizable findings, and the study does not measure performance. The article closes with implications for SMEs and a research agenda based on primary data from both sides of the dyad.