Educational Psychology Review Образование
Reconsidering Instruction Followed by Problem Solving (I-PS): A Systematic Review Focusing on Design Features
Аннотация
Cultivating deep understanding is widely recognized as a central goal of learning. Recent findings in instructional science have indicated that Problem Solving followed by Instruction (PS-I) improves deep understanding compared to the opposite sequence of Instruction followed by Problem Solving (I-PS), particularly when considering specific design features. However, although prior research has thoroughly examined the design features of PS-I, the lack of investigation into the design features of I-PS raises questions regarding the validity of current conclusions. The current study draws attention to the design features of I-PS to provide a more balanced understanding of both sequences. Specifically, we propose a potential I-PS design feature and subsequently conduct a systematic review to compare PS-I with I-PS while considering both key PS-I and I-PS design features. The potential I-PS design feature refers to a provision of tasks that deepen learners’ understanding beyond procedural knowledge during the problem-solving phase. The review revealed that few experiments considered both key PS-I and I-PS design features, indicating that prior comparisons between the sequences may not be sufficient for evaluating relative superiority. Furthermore, the results offered preliminary suggestions that the potential I-PS design feature enhances I-PS effectiveness for deep understanding. These findings highlight a clear need to examine the key I-PS design feature to ensure balanced, rigorous future comparisons. We also discuss practical implications of attending to the design features of I-PS, the limited scope of the current results, and a research agenda for future studies.