Folia Microbiologica Микробиология
Bacillus safensis versus Bacillus pumilus as emerging probiotic candidates: taxonomic reliability, safety, and translational readiness
Аннотация
Spore-forming Bacillus are being investigated as probiotic candidates because of their stability and diverse functional traits. The closely related Bacillus safensis and Bacillus pumilus have different published evidence profiles, but species-level comparisons are constrained by heterogeneous methods, strain identification and intended hosts. This structured critical review appraises strain-designated reports across taxonomic confidence, safety, host outcomes, mechanistic integration and application-specific readiness. Of 12 B. safensis and 24 B. pumilus original study entries, four reports lacked a recoverable individual strain designation; the resulting provisional name-coded sets contain 11 and 21 entries, respectively, not genome-confirmed independent isolates. Separately administered host-outcome investigations are documented for 6/11 and 18/21 entries, including null outcomes; these proportions measure evidence coverage, not the frequency of successful probiotics. B. pumilus research includes SE5 and LV149 lines with linked host and molecular evidence, while selected B. safensis studies report genome-informed identification or repeated-dose toxicology in different strains. Neither profile supports a species-wide ranking of efficacy, safety or market readiness. No controlled human benefit attributable to a defined focal strain was established in the critically appraised evidence. Priorities are strain verification, appropriate safety testing, independently replicated target-host efficacy and reproducible product quality.