Journal of Computing in Higher Education Education
The balancing act between AI and creativity: a case study of university students’ use of generative AI in online group assessment
Abstract
As the demand for cultivating students’ higher-order thinking skills increase, group assessment in online collaborative learning, which is a learning strategy integrating collaborative learning and peer feedback, becomes more necessary for improving students’ learning performance and higher-order thinking abilities. However, in assessment practices, this learning strategy faces challenges due to inconsistent quality of group assessments, students’ inadequate evaluative competence, and low willingness to participate. Recently, generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has provided support for addressing these problems. This study designed a GenAI-supported online group assessment teaching model and conducted a quasi-experimental study in a university elective course. Thirty students participated in the study and were divided into 10 groups. The results showed that GenAI-supported group assessment could significantly enhance students’ task performance, feedback quality, and critical thinking. However, the study also found that using GenAI tools in group assessment somewhat undermined the students’ generation of novel ideas during group discussions. The findings revealed that when adopting GenAI tools in group assessment, it is essential to maintain a proper balance between technical assistance and learners’ independent thinking. This conclusion lays theoretical foundations and offers practical implications for promoting the deeper integration of GenAI into the teaching process.