Cell Communication and Signaling Молекулярная биология

Method matters: a comparative evaluation of tissue-derived extracellular vesicle isolation methods in non-small cell lung cancer

Biernacka, Anna, Faktor, Jakub, Siewiera, Martyna, Papak, Ines, Piróg, Artur, Urban-Wójciuk, Zuzanna, Sitkiewicz, Magdalena, Szczepanowska, Magdalena, Marjański, Tomasz, Rzyman, Witold, Zebrowska, Aneta, Pietrowska, Monika, Gutowska-Owsiak, Danuta, Kote, Sachin, Marek-Trzonkowska, Natalia Maria
Springer Nature · 2026-11-14 · DOI 10.1186/s12964-026-03355-4

Аннотация

Background Tumor-derived small extracellular vesicles (sEVs), including exosomes, affect immune cell function and contribute to the establishment of an immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment. Most studies on tumor-derived sEVs focus on vesicles isolated from cancer cell-conditioned media, but these may differ substantially from those present in the native tumor microenvironment. Direct isolation of sEVs from tumor tissue offers a more biologically relevant approach, but isolated material is often contaminated with intracellular material, protein aggregates, and blood-derived components, making the choice of isolation method critical for reliable downstream analyses. Results In this study, we compared six EV isolation methods for non-small cell lung cancer tissue: ultracentrifugation, iodixanol-cushioned ultracentrifugation, and four commercial kits based on vesicle precipitation, membrane affinity, immunoaffinity, and phosphatidylserine binding. Using transmission electron microscopy, CD9-targeted fluorescence nanoparticle tracking analysis, and quantitative LC-MS/MS proteomics, we assessed the isolated preparations based on characteristics relevant to sEV characterization, including particle size, vesicle morphology, CD9⁺ particle abundance, and EV-associated protein enrichment. Ultracentrifugation and iodixanol-cushioned ultracentrifugation yielded samples showing the strongest evidence of sEV enrichment, as indicated by vesicle morphology, abundance of CD9⁺ particles, and enrichment of EV-associated proteins. The phosphatidylserine-binding approach resulted in moderate sEV enrichment, whereas the other tested approaches predominantly isolated non-vesicular contaminants. While iodixanol-cushioned ultracentrifugation achieved the highest purity, ultracentrifugation provided comparable purity with considerably higher yield of CD9⁺ particles, used here as a proxy for sEV recovery. Conclusions Overall, ultracentrifugation offers the best balance between purity and isolation efficiency, making it a practical choice for tissue-derived EV studies and downstream molecular analyses in solid tumors. Graphical abstract

Читать у издателя →