Trees Biological sciences

Summer climatic controls on oak’s radial growth: a multilevel meta-analysis of climate-growth relationships and moderator effects

Xu, Mingyue, Zeng, Xiaomin, Li, Quanxi, Chen, Xiaoqi, Liu, Xiaohong, Zhang, Haiqin
Springer Nature · 2026-10-30 · DOI 10.1007/s00468-026-02841-z

Abstract

Key message Oak radial growth responses to summer climate are primarily structured by water-balance dynamics and shaped by environmental context and species drought tolerance. Abstract Global warming is increasingly altering climate constraints on forest growth, particularly for widespread and ecologically important tree taxa such as oak, which dominate many temperate forests and provide critical ecosystem functions. However, the relative importance of different summer climatic drivers and the mechanisms underlying their effects on oak radial growth remain poorly synthesized across the Northern Hemisphere. Employing a multilevel meta-analytic approach, we systematically quantified the associations between summer climatic variables (temperature, precipitation, and the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI)) and oak radial growth based on 241 effect sizes from 60 publications, while also evaluating the moderating roles of leaf habit, drought tolerance, region, proxy type, seasonal timing (month), and SPEI timescale. Results indicated that summer temperature was negatively associated with oak radial growth, whereas summer precipitation and SPEI showed positive associations. Precipitation sensitivity was strongest in June, while the pooled SPEI effect across reported timescales was the strongest among the three climatic factors and increased with SPEI timescale. SPEI responses also varied geographically and with species-level drought tolerance, highlighting the context dependence of oak sensitivity to summer water availability. Overall, these findings emphasize the importance of water availability for oak radial growth during the summer growing season and provide a quantitative basis for understanding its climate sensitivity under future warming.

Read at publisher →