Food Security Исследования развития

Dryland cereal systems under aridity: Systematic evidence on maize and pearl millet yield performance

Narmandakh, Davaatseren, Marenya, Paswel P., Sileshi, Gudeta W., Drabo, Inoussa, Nas, Tamerlane M., Peter, Brad G., Sonder, Kai, Snapp, Sieglinde
Springer Nature · 2026-12-01 · DOI 10.1007/s12571-026-01705-1

Аннотация

Millets, native crops to the African drylands, have been largely displaced from agricultural systems and diets by maize, and are now considered underutilized crops. Consequently, there is growing interest among crop scientists and development experts in supporting a renaissance of millet cultivation, alongside other indigenous crops. Yet, the often-cited superiority of millet in marginal environments—especially when compared to maize and sorghum—is rarely backed by rigorous comparisons. This study addresses this gap using a pooled dataset of 14,284 pearl millet, maize, and sorghum yield observations from a systematic review, analyzed through spline and logit regression and crop suitability modelling, across aridity zones in sub-Saharan Africa. The dataset—as does the broader literature—lacks side-by-side field comparisons. Crop performances were therefore evaluated instead along an aridity gradient. Results indicate that maize outyields millet and sorghum in almost all aridity zones. However, maize yields were variable compared to the low but relatively stable yield observed for pearl millet. High maize yields likely reflect the performances of hybrid maize, with seed and input costs that may reduce the profit advantage for smallholders, which raw yield data taken in isolation would suggest. Pearl millet also offers nutritional advantages, including higher iron, zinc, and protein contents, which are not captured in yield (biomass) comparisons. Local factors such as soil type and agronomic management could not be accounted for, although these are expected to condition crop performances. A systems approach that accounts for local context is necessary to evaluate the comparative advantage of these staple cereals.

Читать у издателя →