AWWA Water Science Filtration and Separation

Conditions for Evaluating PAC Against GAC to Control PFAS in Drinking Water

Anthony Kennedy, Kyle Hay, Steven Shiokari, Christopher Corwin
Wiley · 2026-09-01 · DOI 10.1002/aws2.70068

Abstract

ABSTRACT Activated carbon is expected to be widely applied to meet perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctanoic sulfonic acid (PFOS) maximum contaminant levels (MCL) of 4 ng/L in drinking water. Theoretical dose ratio relationships suggest powdered activated carbon (PAC) should become more favorable than granular activated carbon (GAC) as removal requirements decrease. Accordingly, PAC and GAC were evaluated at bench‐scale under realistic conditions across six different public water systems using surface water as their source water. Observed trends generally followed an increase in PAC favorability as removal requirements decreased, but not as exaggerated as theory suggested. A linear relationship developed between common PAC and GAC products identified an inflection point at ~43% PFOA and PFOS removal and was used to develop adsorbent cost relationships based on varying their relative unit costs. Non‐cost factors were also presented that may influence adsorbent selection more than their relative doses.

Read at publisher →