BMC Medical Education Образование
Choosing simulation modalities for cardiac arrest training: a mixed-methods evaluation informed by functional task alignment
Аннотация
Background Simulation-based education is resource intensive, creating pressure for feasible delivery as its use expands across health professions education. Understanding how the growing range of simulation technologies can support scalable delivery of important educational objectives while providing a useful participant experience remains important. Methods We conducted a pragmatic sequential mixed-methods observational evaluation across two Australian simulation centres, using functional task alignment as a sensitising conceptual lens. Adult cardiac arrest simulation events using three implementation packages with broadly similar learning objectives were enrolled. Learners and faculty completed post-event surveys assessing perceived realism and whether realism was perceived as sufficient for learning; this latter item was prospectively designated as the principal quantitative survey outcome. Event-level implementation characteristics, including faculty headcount, were also recorded. Quantitative data are summarised descriptively. Nine simulation educators and programme contributors subsequently participated in a semi-structured focus group analysed using codebook thematic analysis to explore perspectives on realism, simulation modality selection and implementation. Results Quantitative analysis included 24 simulation events and 188 participation opportunities; 110 surveys were returned (58.5%). Median ratings for perceived sufficiency of realism for learning were 8/9, 8/9 and 7/9 for high-fidelity manikin-based, app-based and virtual-reality simulation, respectively. Median ratings for patient responses and sounds were 7/9, 5/9 and 5/9, while median overall perceived fidelity ratings were 8/9, 6/9 and 7/9, respectively. Faculty headcount per event also varied across the observed implementation packages. These descriptive observations do not establish statistical differences, educational equivalence or causal effects. Qualitative analysis identified three themes: (i) realism was shaped by narrative, context, engagement and alignment with learning objectives; (ii) technology could redistribute rather than simply reduce implementation workload; and (iii) modality selection should reflect learning objectives and local context. Conclusions Simulation modality selection should be guided by functional task alignment, learner needs, faculty capability, reliability and local implementation context rather than technological sophistication or perceived fidelity alone.