Attention, Perception, & Psychophysics Humanities and social sciences
Are cueing effects really “negligible” when accuracy is emphasized and single masks eliminate uncertainty about target location?
Abstract
Abstract Does spatial attention operate primarily by minimizing decision-related noise or by enhancing information from the attended location? While emphasizing and only reporting accuracy, Shiu and Pashler ( Journal of Experimental Psychology. Human Perception and Performance , 20 (5), 1037–1054, 1994 ) found “negligible” effects of spatial pre-cues when uncertainty about the target’s location was eliminated by a single mask, a finding often cited in favor of the idea that spatial pre-cues improve performance by reducing uncertainty (and not by signal enhancement). In a similar, single-mask condition, and while emphasizing reaction time (RT), Prasad and Hommel ( Experimental Psychology, 71 (3):135-143, 2024 ), found significant cueing effects in reaction time and accuracy, which is consistent with signal enhancement. Stimulated by this empirical discrepancy, we implemented the fundamental methods of these studies to explore how invalid versus valid cues affected participant RT and accuracy. In each of two experiments we included a speed-stress manipulation: emphasizing response speed in one group and accuracy in the other. In Experiment 1 , clear cueing effects were found in RT and accuracy across all conditions. In Experiment 2 , with randomized single- and multiple-mask trials rather than blocked, the consistent cueing effects found in E1 were generally supported. Importantly, regardless of speed versus accuracy emphasis, we found robust cueing effects in the single-mask condition in both RT and accuracy. Whereas our results support signal enhancement as one mechanism of cueing effects, we acknowledge that multiple mechanisms may be operating to affect performance in a Posner-style cueing paradigm. Open practices statement The studies presented here were preregistered on the Open Science Framework (OSF). The preregistrations, raw (trial-level) data from both experiments, experimental code, and analysis script can all be found can be found at: https://osf.io/2dcvj/