Sugar Tech Agronomy and Crop Science

Long-Term Comparative Evaluation of Organic and Conventional Farming Systems on Sugar Yield, Soil Fertility, and Economic Returns in Sugarcane

Sreelatha, T., Ramalakshmi, Ch. S., Saritha, R., Sireesha, A., Adilakshmi, D., Rao, D. Purushotama
Springer Nature · 2026-12-01 · DOI 10.1007/s12355-026-01800-9

Abstract

A long-term field experiment was conducted to evaluate the sustainability and performance of organic and conventional sugarcane farming systems under the tropical semi-arid conditions of coastal Andhra Pradesh, India. The study ran for 14 consecutive years (2011–12 to 2024–25) at the Regional Agricultural Research Station, Anakapalle, using a randomized block design with two farming systems: organic farming (OF) and conventional farming (CF). The investigation assessed cane yield, yield attributes, juice quality, soil properties, microbial populations, and economic returns. Two-way ANOVA showed that treatment effects had no significant impact on cane yield and yield attributes, juice quality parameters, economic elements, soil physicochemical, nutrient, and microbe parameters, except phosphate-solubilizing bacteria (PSB), indicating comparable performance of the two farming systems. Organic farming recorded numerically higher mean values for cane yield (72.38 t ha⁻^1), sugar yield (9.64 t ha⁻^1), sucrose (18.75%), commercial cane sugar (13.05%), soil organic carbon (0.71%), and net returns (₹180,527 ha⁻^1), whereas conventional farming maintained higher available soil nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. Soil health indicators were significantly improved under organic farming, evidenced by higher soil organic carbon (0.71%), lower electrical conductivity (0.20 dS m⁻^1), and stable pH, although treatment differences were not statistically significant. Among the microbial parameters, the population of phosphate-solubilizing bacteria (PSB) was the only trait with a significant treatment effect. Organic farming had much higher counts at 13.81 × 10^3 cfu g⁻^1 compared to conventional farming at 6.67 × 10^3 cfu g⁻^1, while the differences in Azospirillum and Azotobacter populations were not significant. Economic analysis showed similar profitability between the two farming systems. Organic farming had slightly higher net returns (₹180,527 ha⁻^1) and a benefit–cost ratio (0.88), but these differences were not statistically significant. This study was conducted at a single location with a single sugarcane variety, so the findings may not generalize to all agro-climatic conditions. More validation is necessary before applying the results broadly. Future research should test multiple sugarcane varieties across different agro-ecological regions with long-term organic management.

Read at publisher →