International Journal of Primatology Экология, эволюция, поведение и систематика
Can camera trap distance sampling outperform line transects for estimating arboreal and semi-terrestrial primate density?
Аннотация
Accurate estimates of wildlife population density are vital for conservation planning but remain difficult to obtain for many species. Line transect distance sampling (LTDS) has been the standard for primate density estimation, yet its reliability is often compromised by violations of assumptions caused by species behavior and observer disturbance. Camera trap distance sampling (CTDS) offers a noninvasive alternative that can overcome some limitations, while introducing new sources of bias. We compared LTDS and CTDS in terms of estimates precision, ecological plausibility, and associated detection performance, costs, effort requirements, and spatial coverage for two sympatric primates with contrasting ecologies in West Bali National Park, Indonesia: the semi-terrestrial long-tailed macaque ( Macaca fascicularis ) and the arboreal Javan langur ( Trachypithecus auratus ). We deployed 30 camera traps on a systematic grid over 2,632 camera-days, alongside 206.5 km of pedestrian line transects. For macaques, LTDS yielded lower estimates (17 individuals/km^2, CV = 47%), while CTDS produced more precise and ecologically consistent values (33 individuals/km^2, CV = 29%), reaching 100 independent detections in just 284 camera-days. For langurs, LTDS was more precise (23 individuals/km^2, CV = 16%) while CTDS required terrestriality estimates based on direct observation, potentially introducing bias (16 individuals/km^2, CV = 28%). Camera trap distance sampling incurred higher costs and data processing times, but LTDS demanded greater field effort and yielded fewer detections. Overall, our findings highlight CTDS as a powerful tool that can reduce field effort and improve density estimation for semi-terrestrial primates, with promising applications for arboreal species when ground availability is properly accounted for.