German Journal of Exercise and Sport Research Physical Therapy, Sports Therapy and Rehabilitation

Top-level management in German professional football

Dombrowski, Matthias, Hovemann, Gregor, Hodeck, Alexander
Springer Nature · 2026-09-01 · DOI 10.1007/s12662-026-01150-4

Abstract

Background This study examines the relationship between top-level management characteristics in German professional football clubs and their sporting and economic performance, drawing on upper echelons theory to explain how executive backgrounds and experiences may influence organizational outcomes. To compare the Bundesliga and 2nd Bundesliga, factors such as personnel composition, continuity, and educational background were examined in relation to both sporting and economic performance. Methods A quantitative state and performance analysis was conducted using data from 36 German professional football clubs over six seasons (2016/2017–2021/2022). Key variables included personnel changes, the proportion of former players, academic qualifications, sports-specific education, and management size. Sporting and economic indicators were correlated with management characteristics, and clubs were categorized into performance clusters to explore similarities and differences. Results Bundesliga clubs exhibited fewer personnel changes, higher academic qualifications (75% vs. 62%), and larger management teams, each of which correlated with better performance. Clubs in the top third of the 2nd Bundesliga showed higher turnover and a greater presence of former professional players. A significant relationship was identified between management size and performance rankings ( r = −0.428, p = 0.009). Former players were more prevalent in mid-tier clubs and in clubs with promotion or relegation ambitions. Conclusion Personnel continuity, management size, and academic qualifications appear positively associated with performance, particularly in the Bundesliga. Former players can contribute value when closely connected to their clubs, while higher turnover in football-specific roles points to instability in clubs facing difficulties. Sports-specific education showed no association with success. These findings underscore the value of clear managerial structures, continuity, and targeted development pathways in supporting long-term performance. Future research should integrate qualitative perspectives and broaden the analysis to additional leagues and sports.

Read at publisher →