Educational Psychology Review Образование

Metacognitive Illusions About Prequestioning Are Attenuated with Refutation Texts and Test Design

Pan, Steven C., Chua, Tabitha J. E., Rivers, Michelle L., Teo, Nathaneal W. E.
Springer Nature · 2026-11-17 · DOI 10.1007/s10648-026-10232-6

Аннотация

Prequestioning involves making guesses to questions about unfamiliar material prior to discovering the correct answers in text passages, lectures, or other sources. Although it can enhance learning relative to non-guessing activities—i.e., the prequestioning effect —learners may not recognize its benefits. Across five experiments, we examined the extent to which learners exhibit metacognitive awareness of the prequestioning effect and tested supports designed to improve such awareness. In each experiment, learners experienced up to two cycles of prequestioning and reading factual statements, reading an expository text, and taking a criterial test. Learners also made metacognitive judgments—including predictions and postdictions of test performance—during each cycle. Across experiments, prequestioning consistently yielded better test performance than reading statements, with large effects (Cohen’s d = 0.83–1.35). Nevertheless, learners incorrectly predicted and postdicted better performance from reading statements (Experiment 1). Performance feedback did not eliminate that metacognitive illusion (Experiment 2), but separating test items by prior learning technique was associated with more accurate postdictions (Experiment 3). Adding a refutation text countering misconceptions about prequestioning improved prediction and postdiction accuracy (Experiment 4), although only predictions improved without feedback or separating test items by learning technique (Experiment 5). Reading was preferred for future learning in Experiment 1, whereas prequestioning was viewed more favorably in later experiments. Overall, these findings reveal substantial underappreciation of prequestioning’s benefits, underscoring the need for external measures to increase their visibility. Beyond direct experience and performance feedback, assessment structure, background information, and refuting misconceptions appear to improve metacognitive awareness regarding prequestioning.

Читать у издателя →