From Grounding to Interpretation: A Free-Energy Formulation of Deacon’s Absentialist Dynamics

Entomological Review · Springer Nature · 2026-10-08 · DOI: 10.1007/s12304-026-09666-w

Аннотация

Terrence Deacon's (2021) account of how molecules become signs tells us what a sign is at the molecular level, but not how it works dynamically. It does not say where physical grounding gives way to interpretation, nor how a grounding event comes to matter for a system's fate. We supply that missing dynamics from the free energy principle (FEP), and our central claim is simple to state: the epistemic cut that Howard Pattee placed between physical law and symbolic rule is instituted by a system's self-produced Markov blanket, and what Deacon calls interpretation is the self-maintaining, prediction-error-minimizing loop that the blanket closes. We are careful about the strength of this claim: Pattee's distinction is modal and the blanket's is topological, so we argue not that the two coincide but that the self-produced blanket is what individuates a system for which anything can be rate-independent at all. To keep the claim disciplined we separate the weak FEP, a mathematical principle for any system with a non-equilibrium steady state and a Markov blanket, from the strong process theory of active inference, confining cognitive predicates to the latter. We then show that variational free-energy minimization corresponds structurally to Deacon's expected work-saving. This gives biosemiotics what the autogen thought-experiment lacked: a definite place to locate the epistemic cut, and a measurable dynamics for interpretation. A companion study extends the formulation into a five-level emergence model and derives empirical predictions.

Читать у издателя →

Похожие статьи