Landscape and Ecological Engineering Ecology
Primary vegetation recovery and development of an evaluation framework following fifteen years of alien plant control on the subtropical oceanic island of Anijima, Ogasawara
Abstract
Evaluation is essential for alien plant control projects aimed at restoring native vegetation. However, restoration targets often consist of a constellation of ecosystem states shaped by environmental heterogeneity, making it difficult to identify appropriate reference ecosystems for individual sites. Comprehensive evaluation frameworks that address this complexity remain limited. In this study, we developed a restoration evaluation framework for heterogeneous ecosystems and applied it to a long-term alien plant control project on Anijima Island in the subtropical oceanic Ogasawara Islands, Japan. The project aimed to restore primary dry scrub forests, grasslands, and bare-land ecosystems through alien plant removal. Using additional vegetation surveys and long-term monitoring data, we evaluated restoration progress with two complementary reference settings: one based on native and alien plant cover for early-stage recovery, and another based on species composition and vertical structure for later-stage recovery. We quantified restoration progress using ordination-based nearest-reference dissimilarity metrics and compared the results with those from a group-to-group comparison using PERMANOVA. Alien plant control substantially reduced total alien plant cover immediately after removal, but reinvasion after initial removal was common. Some native species recovered in the shrub and herb layers. However, community composition and dominance structure did not consistently converge toward reference native vegetation; instead, some communities shifted away from reference vegetation over time. The proposed framework successfully detected these deviations. Evaluation using internationally recognized restoration attributes indicated that alien species rebound, continued invasion pressure, and limited self-sustainability remain major challenges for restoration.