Tension and Ambivalence of Religion and Public Health in Adolescent and Youth Sexual and Reproductive Health (AYSRH) in South Africa: An Ambivalence Intervention Framework for Effective AYSRH Outcomes
Аннотация
Churches and other faith-based organisations are often said to play a conflicting double role in adolescent and youth sexual and reproductive health (AYSRH). They help to carry health messages and support community interventions, yet they also oppose public health strategies that clash with doctrine, and this sustains a persistent tension between faith communities and public health establishments. Drawing on a qualitative study conducted in the Vaal Triangle region of South Africa, this article proposes ambivalence as a normative and potentially constructive concept for interpreting and engaging that tension. The study used an interpretive descriptive design within a pragmatic paradigm. Over seven months, data were collected through 16 in-depth interviews with pastors, school principals, and government officials, and through eight focus group discussions with parents, church-going youth, and Technical and Vocational Education and Training college students, giving a total of 24 data-collection sessions. Participants were recruited purposively, so a response rate was not calculated. The findings identify four recurring areas of ambivalence that characterise church–public health tensions on AYSRH: (i) divergent conceptions of sexuality and health, (ii) resistance to condoms, (iii) uncertainty about the adequacy of inherited church messages, and (iv) the non-negotiable centrality of God’s plan in church reasoning. The ambivalence is normative and largely irreconcilable because it rests on two competing epistemological worlds, a theological perspective informed by religious texts and a public health paradigm grounded in human rights. The article proposes a two-part ambivalence intervention framework, made up of a diagnostic tool for locating church and public health positions on AYSRH and a position-shift model that guides collaboration through joint exploration, negotiation, transparency about values, willingness to learn from others, identification of connection points, and recognition of shared interests. Adding a spiritual dimension to the working definition of AYSRH helps to explain why churches respond as they do and gives faith-public health engagement a more realistic starting point.