Veterinary Surgery General Veterinary

Accuracy of intraoperative gross margin assessment by veterinary surgeons compared with histologic margin evaluation: A multicenter prospective cohort study

Mason Hill, Giovanni Tremolada, Janis Lapsley, Laura Selmic, Samuella Boadi, Jacob Oleson, Hunter Piegols
Wiley · 2026-11-13 · DOI 10.1111/vsu.70178

Abstract

Abstract Objective To identify the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), and accuracy of intraoperative surgeon‐perceived margin status via gross examination compared to histologic evaluation for marginal and wide cutaneous mass excisions. Study design Multicenter prospective cohort study. Animal population A total of 84 dogs and six cats with 102 cutaneous masses. Methods Four surgeons completed a survey assessing margin completeness after mass removal prior to histologic results. Results Surgeon ability to identify incomplete margins had a sensitivity of 56.3%, specificity of 87.2%, PPV of 45%, NPV of 91.5%, and accuracy of 82.4%. Surgeon margin assessment was correct in 58.5% of marginally excised and 98.4% of widely excised masses: odds ratio (OR) 0.024 (confidence interval [CI]: 0.003, 0.19). Margin assessment based upon cytologic malignancy status was correct in nine of 14 (64.3%) benign lesions and 75 of 88 (85.2%) malignant lesions: OR 0.31 (CI: 0.09, 1.1). Conclusion Surgeons did not have improved accuracy in margin assessment for cytologically benign masses compared with malignant masses. Surgeon margin assessment correctness may be influenced by surgical dose. Additionally, when surgeons suspected a complete margin, there was a high probability that the histologic margin was complete. Limitations included the diversity of cases enrolled, few participating surgeons, potential non‐blinded assessment bias, and lack of clinical follow up. Clinical significance Veterinary surgeons can provide owners an assessment of margin completeness with a degree of confidence for wide mass excision. Caution should persist in assessment of marginally excised tumors. This information allows owners to contemplate further treatment pending histopathology results.

Read at publisher →