Journal of Software: Evolution and Process Software
A Goal‐Driven Method for Software Selection
Abstract
ABSTRACT Solutions and business architects play a fundamental role in the process of selecting software solutions that satisfy their organizations' objectives and needs to implement a change. These practitioners are often faced with the challenge of selecting the most suitable software among a set of candidate solutions. For that, they often perform a comparative study based on a set of criteria to select the software that best meets the specific needs of their organizations and customers. The software selection is a decision process that plays a crucial role in organizations' digital transformation. However, existing methods have limitations related to their usability and implementation complexity. This paper provides architecture practitioners with a novel method that automatically prioritizes software solutions in order to select the most suitable one. The prioritization process of the solutions is based on: (i) the functional requirements they implement and (ii) the desired goals (business objectives and non‐functional requirements) they satisfy. The proposed method is goal‐oriented. It uses the Goal‐oriented Requirement Language (GRL) that links the candidate software to the requirements to be implemented and the goals to be met. The use of GRL allows the method to automatically compute satisfaction scores that measure the effectiveness of candidate software solutions in implementing requirements and satisfying the desired goals. The satisfaction score is used to rank the software solutions. An experimental study was conducted to evaluate the method's usability. Results demonstrated its effectiveness and alignment with expert expectations in solutions, business architecture, and business analysis.