The Opacity Penalty in Digital Banking: How Technology Distributes SME Credit Constraints

Korosteleva, Julia, Kozłowski, Łukasz, Rzepka, Malwina, Hryckiewicz, Aneta, Wang, Ruomeng
Journal of Financial Services Research · Springer Nature · 2026-11-17 · DOI: 10.1007/s10693-026-00478-0

Abstract

This paper investigates how bank digitalization affects credit supply within established SME lending relationships using panel data linking 179,921 European SMEs to 54 relationship banks across 15 countries (2009–2019) and a novel index of bank technology adoption. We find that bank digitalization increases average long-term debt growth by approximately 0.10% points, offsetting around 12% of sample-period deleveraging, with effects concentrated in long-term credit and substantially weaker for short-term credit. The aggregate effect masks a strong distributional effect, documenting that long-term credit growth declines for the smallest existing customers, and increases for the largest, generating a 0.18%-point gap between the two. These findings persist across various institutional environments and are robust to a difference-in-differences design that exploits the EU’s Payment Services Directive and to instrumental-variables estimation using Google Trends index. This evidence implies that bank digitalization systematically redistributes credit growth toward more transparent borrowers within existing banking relationships, rather than democratizing credit access across the SME population, thereby challenging optimism about banking sector digitalization.

Read at publisher →

Similar articles