Argumentation
Издатель: Springer Nature · ISSN 0920-427X,1572-8374 · 24 статей
-
Arguing without Polemic: Strategic Maneuvering in the European Union’s Nationally Determined Contribution
This study examines how argumentation operates in institutional contexts where disagreement is procedurally suppressed, focusing on the European Union’s updated Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) submitted under the Paris...
-
When decorum seems to fail: from authority-based ethos to similarity-based ethos
This article offers a philosophical reinterpretation of the classical rhetorical principle of decorum in the context of contemporary public communication. It examines how linguistic forms traditionally regarded as inappropriate,...
-
“Blood Like Wine; it Rages in Youth, it Ripens with Age:” An Empirical Study of Age and Interpersonal Arguing in Poland
This study surveys orientations toward interpersonal arguing in Poland, using subsamples of younger (mean age = 21.4 years, n = 208) and older (mean age = 70 years, n = 170) respondents. The primary aim of the study was to compare the...
-
Strategic Maneuvering Oriented toward “A Harmonious Family Flourishes” : A Pragma-Dialectical Analysis of Chinese Family Mediation Discourse
Family mediation discourse integrates cultural norms, communicative strategies and dispute settlement reasoning. Drawing on corpus data from a mainstream Chinese televised mediation program, this paper applies a pragma-dialectical...
-
Making the Arguer Visible: Reconstruction Practices and the Representation of Speaker Intent
Argument reconstruction is typically treated as a technical procedure aimed at identifying underlying argumentative content. In this article, however, we show that reconstruction actively shapes how the speaker is represented in...
-
The Implicit Audience Problem in Computational Argument Quality Assessment: A Pragmatic Critique and the ASAQ Framework
This paper identifies a structural tension in computational argument quality assessment. Although the influential framework of Wachsmuth et al. (2017a, b) explicitly invokes a target audience in its dimensional definitions, its...
-
Adversarial Alignment in Argumentation
This article introduces adversarial alignment to describe a form of argumentative coordination in which interventions associated with normatively divergent positions reinforce one another against a shared adversary. Building on...
-
Arguer’s Identity and Authorization for Phatic and Emotive Moves: A Proposal for an Extension to Inference Anchoring Theory
This paper proposes an extension of Inference Anchoring Theory (IAT) that incorporates speaker-centered pragmatic phenomena: arguer identity, phatic speech acts, and emotive speech acts into the analysis of natural-language...
-
Prototypical Argumentative Patterns in Chinese Diplomatic Statements at United Nations Security Council Meetings on the Ukraine Crisis
Based on the pragma-dialectical theory of argumentation, this study concentrates on describing the prototypical argumentative patterns utilized by Chinese representatives at United Nations Security Council meetings on the Ukraine...
- James B. Freeman: Adequate Connections: Assessing Argument Ground Adequacy: Argumentation Library 38: Cham, Switzerland, Springer 2025, xiii + 179 pp., 11 b/w figures
-
Biased Reasoning, Argument Analysis, and the Principle of Charity
A significant proportion of human reasoning is systematically biased, a fact that sits uneasily with argumentation theory’s methodological commitment to the principle of charity. Traditionally, the principle requires arguments to be...
-
Linguistic Choices and Argumentative Effects: An Experimental Investigation of Presentational Means in the ‘Van Gelder’ Court Case
This study assesses whether the linguistic choices that Van Haaften and Van Leeuwen identified in the so-called ‘Van Gelder’ court case (as reported in a.o. Journal of Argumentation in Context 10 (1), 97-120, 2021) have empirically...
-
Empirical evidence for the non-persuasiveness of the straw man on its target
This paper addresses the degree to which straw man arguments are perceived as persuasive by their targets. A review of the literature shows that there is a consensus on the topic, stipulating that using a straw man argument is unlikely...
-
Sensitivity to Quality Variations of Conflicting Arguments
Experimental argumentation research allows researchers to test normative predictions from argumentation theory. In the domain of argument quality, for instance, numerous studies have supported the prediction that high-quality arguments...
- Review of the Volume: Ana María Mora Márquez and Gustavo Fernández Walker (Eds.) (2025), Revisiting Medieval Dialectics, Springer, Argumentation Library, 255 pp
-
Orientations toward Interpersonal Arguing in Ukraine, Across Three War Conditions
This is a natural experiment comparing Ukrainians’ orientations toward interpersonal arguing under three distinct conditions of war. We compare results of parallel data collections from 2018 (after the Crimea seizure but before the...
-
The Civic Argument Literacy Test (CALT) – Foundations and Development
The Civic Argument Literacy Test (CALT) is a new instrument for measuring how individuals recognise, interpret, and evaluate arguments in civic discourse. This research essay sets out the conceptual and theoretical foundations of the...
- Benefits, Diversity, and Prospects of Experimental Methods in Argumentation
-
The Discourse-Directive Function of Loci in the Argument Model of Topics
In argumentation theory, loci - also referred to as topoi - are commonly viewed as abstract sources of inference that guide the invention of arguments. Within the Argument Model of Topics (AMT), loci are analysed as sources of inference...
-
Argumentation Flaws in Institutional Handling of an Allegation of Research Misconduct
Research misconduct and questionable research practices are increasingly documented across academic disciplines, including the biomedical and social sciences, in parallel with transformations in university governance, evaluation...
-
AI-Authorship Accusations Against Human Discussants: A Pragma-Dialectical Account of Procedural Derailment
This paper offers a pragma-dialectical reconstruction of AI-authorship accusations directed at human discussants: the charge that a contribution is machine-generated or not attributable to a responsible participant. Such an accusation...
-
The Identity Function of Argumentation in Religious Discourse: A Comparative Case Study
In this paper we examine how identity is affirmed through the use of arguments in religious discourse. We consider both the structure of the arguments employed and the form of their presentation in terms of linguistic characteristics...
-
Argumentation Absent Understanding: Minimal Threshold Conditions for Epistemically Adequate Uptake
This article examines a gap between argument-as-object evaluation and uptake-in-context evaluation. An argument may be cogent while an addressee accepts its conclusion without preserving the conditions under which it is warranted. To...
-
Invitational Rhetoric and Persuasion Rhetoric: Aligning Argumentative Influence with Epistemic Agency
This paper advances a unified account of how argumentative influence can align with epistemic agency by reframing the distinction between invitational and persuasion rhetoric. Drawing on Foss and Griffin’s (1995) influential...