Asian Journal of Philosophy Философия

The explanatory power of memory traces: against Bergson

Perrin, Denis
Springer Nature · 2026-11-11 · DOI 10.1007/s44204-026-00455-3

Аннотация

As Hirai’s target paper argues, rightly I think, Bergson offers an interesting moderate critical view of the role and explanatory power of traces in memory. In this commentary paper, I will take issue with Bergson’s view. I will argue that Bergson’s arguments for a weak explanatory power of traces fail, likewise therefore the argument for the ontological independence of memory with respect to bodily processes based on his critical view of traces. Against Bergson, I will offer arguments to endow traces with more explanatory power, as well as to prefer theories that give stronger power to traces over theories, like Bergson’s, that give them weaker power. Overall, I hope to propose a critical discussion of Bergson’s view of memory from an analytic perspective and feed the conversation between the analytic and the Bergsonian traditions.

Читать у издателя →