An asymmetric sample design for source-oriented diagnostic information in proficiency testing
Аннотация
In proficiency testing (PT), a result outside the satisfactory range may indicate a performance concern without identifying the likely source of the deviation. This study examined whether prior differentiation of sample roles could build additional diagnostic information into PT returns. A matrix-free, pretreatment-free survey sample (SS) was distributed together with a conventional matrix-based, pretreatment-dependent assessment sample (AS) and conventional interference samples, forming an asymmetric sample design. Within the same laboratory return, the paired AS and SS results were treated as proxies for different portions of the analytical workflow. Across 147 paired AS–SS datasets, two diagnostic quantities used for interpretation, $${R}_{\text{S}\text{S}}$$ and the survey-referenced contrast ($$SRC$$), were derived. $${R}_{\text{S}\text{S}}$$ reflected deviation associated with the pretreatment-free portion of the analytical workflow, whereas $$SRC$$ reflected additional deviation associated with the AS-specific portion of the analytical workflow. Representative cases illustrated how these quantities could help narrow the likely source domains of deviations and guide targeted review. The study shows that prior differentiation of sample roles can increase the yield of source-oriented diagnostic information from PT data and support more focused follow-up review and corrective action without replacing established PT performance assessment.