Erkenntnis Philosophy

How the Present will be: Reply to Meyer

Deasy, Daniel
Springer Nature · 2026-10-01 · DOI 10.1007/s10670-025-01050-3

Abstract

Meyer (Erkenntnis 89:463–478, 2024) argues that the Moving Spotlight Theory (MST) of time entails the falsehood of the widely-accepted tense-logical principles that what is true always will have been true (∀ p ( p → GP p )) and that what is true always was going to be true (∀ p ( p → HF p )). In this article, I describe Meyer’s argument as I understand it (Sect. 2 ); argue that MST does not have this strange consequence (Sect. 3 ); and attempt to diagnose the source of Meyer’s error (Sect. 4 ). My aim is not simply to respond to Meyer’s argument on behalf of MST, but to gain a better understanding of the theory and of the source of a certain family of objections that are typically raised against it.

Read at publisher →